Fresh Catch: Must-Make Seafood Recipes with Goat Cheese

There’s a lot to be said about beef, pork, and chicken, but when it comes to elegant entertaining, seafood is a must. Not only is there endless variety to explore, but fresh seafood also provides protein without heaviness and flavor that’s never overpowering. And when paired with creamy, tangy goat cheese, seafood creates some seriously unforgettable meals.
Try our favorite seafood and fish recipes featuring goat cheese at your next gathering.
Crispy Rice Bites with Goat Cheese and Spicy Tuna

First, a spin on an iconic dish. In our version of crispy rice bites with spicy tuna, mix diced tuna with mayonnaise, sriracha, green onion, sesame oil, and lemon juice. Then, pan-fry squares of sushi rice until crispy. Assemble the bites by layering avocado, the tuna mixture, crumbles of Original Goat Cheese, and a drizzle of sriracha on top of the fried rice bites. If you want extra spice, add sliced jalapeño or serrano pepper as a garnish.
Swicy Salmon with Lemon Bar Goat Cheese

If refined is more your style, this swicy salmon recipe delivers. The fish is marinated in a sweet, spicy, and zesty marinade made from brown sugar, red pepper flakes, and red wine vinegar. For a final flourish, the salmon is topped with a velvety, bright sauce made from the leftover marinade and our Lemon Bar Goat Cheese. We like to say Lemon Bar tastes like sunshine, and it brings a lively, beachy finish to this swicy salmon. Summertime vibes, any time of year.
Lemon Pepper Shrimp with Lemon Bar Goat Cheese

Lemon pepper is having a comeback, and we say “yay” to that. You might know it as the classic seasoning your family always used for seafood, and that hit of nostalgia is part of the fun. For this lemon pepper shrimp recipe, sear plump shrimp in a hot pan with lemon pepper, lemon juice, and cracked black pepper. After cooking, toss the shrimp with Lemon Bar Goat Cheese crumbles and herbs. Serve atop pasta for a party-perfect dish with a citrusy, piquant flavor profile.
Bonus: Mussels with Irish Ale Cream and Goat Cheese

We’d be remiss not to recommend pairing mussels with beer and goat cheese. This recipe required some investigation from the author, and it was well worth it. Add toasted baguette slices, and you’ll feel like you’re at a classic seafood restaurant on the East Coast.
How to Shop for Fresh Seafood
There’s nothing worse than getting ready to make food for guests, only to discover that your ingredients are now less-than-fresh. Take these seafood shopping tips to the store next time to make sure you always choose the best that’s available.
Salmon
If you’re buying wild salmon, pay attention to seasonality. These varieties should only be bought fresh when they’re in season.
King/chinook: Late spring to summer
Sockeye: Early summer to late summer
Pink salmon: Late summer to early fall
Coho: Late summer to fall
Alaskan chum: Late summer to early fall
For the best quality, look for salmon that feels firm and springs back when pressed. It should smell mild and clean, not strongly fishy or ammonia-like. Avoid fillets with brown, darkened, or dried-out edges. Out of season? Choose frozen-at-sea wild salmon, which is often just as good as fresh, or responsibly farmed salmon, which is available year-round.
Shrimp
If you’re choosing refrigerated shrimp over frozen, be picky. Look for shrimp with a firm texture, a pearl-like appearance, and little to no odor. Avoid shrimp that smell like ammonia or appear limp, slimy, or like they’re starting to fall apart.
Tuna
Like salmon, tuna should smell mild and clean. The flesh should be firm, moist, and spring back when pressed. Look for vibrant color and avoid pieces with a bloodline (the dark strip of meat that runs through the tuna) that has turned dark brown or black.
Mussels
When shopping for mussels, look for tightly closed shells, a clean ocean smell, and wet, shiny exteriors. Discard any mussels with an open shell before cooking and always prepare mussels the same day that you buy them.
How Much Seafood to Buy for Company
Salmon: 6-8 ounces (1/2 pound) per person
Shrimp: 5-15 shrimp per person (5 for jumbo shrimp, 15 for small shrimp)
Tuna: 6-8 ounces (1/2 pound) per person
Mussels: 1 pound per person
Make Seafood Recipes Shine with LaClare Goat Cheese
With LaClare Creamery goat cheese, you never have to worry about freshness.
Our goat milk makes a short trip to the creamery, so you can always expect a milky, delicate, mild flavor with notes of sweetness. With our beloved Original Goat Cheese and newer additions like Lemon Bar and Ube Goat Cheese, there’s a LaClare cheese to fit all your recipes.



